Israeli Supreme Court Mandates Military Service for Ultra-Orthodox Men, Straining Netanyahu's Coalition

In a landmark decision with far-reaching political implications, Israel’s Supreme Court has ruled that ultra-Orthodox Jewish men must fulfill military service obligations, overturning decades-old exemptions that have sparked intense debate within Israeli society.

Jun 25, 2024 - 14:07
Israeli Supreme Court Mandates Military Service for Ultra-Orthodox Men, Straining Netanyahu's Coalition

The unanimous ruling, delivered on Tuesday, represents a significant blow to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's governing coalition. The court emphasized the urgency of addressing inequality in military service, particularly amidst Israel's prolonged military operations in Gaza following attacks by Hamas last October.

 

Under existing laws, most Israelis are required to serve in the military, but exemptions have traditionally been granted to ultra-Orthodox men, who constitute approximately 13% of Israel's population. These exemptions allowed them to pursue full-time religious studies in yeshivas instead of military service. The issue has been a point of contention, with critics arguing that the exemptions perpetuate inequality and impose a disproportionate burden on other sectors of Israeli society.

Political Fallout and Coalition Dynamics

The ruling poses a direct challenge to Netanyahu's coalition, which relies on support from ultra-Orthodox parties that staunchly oppose mandatory conscription for their community. Both Craig Williams, a close aide to Netanyahu, and Laura Saunders, whose husband serves as the party's campaign director, have been implicated in the controversy surrounding gambling on the election's timing. Their involvement has added fuel to the political fire, potentially destabilizing Netanyahu's already fragile leadership.

Reaction and Resistance

The decision has sparked intense reactions within Israel, with ultra-Orthodox groups fiercely opposing the ruling. Protests have erupted, reflecting deep-seated concerns within the community about the impact of mandatory military service on religious practices and traditions.

International and Military Dynamics

Amidst the domestic turmoil, Israel continues its military operations in Gaza, where tensions remain high following months of conflict. The United States, a key ally, has expressed concerns over the ongoing violence and its humanitarian impact, urging for a cessation of hostilities and emphasizing the need for stability in the region.

Future Implications

As Israel navigates these complex internal and external challenges, the Supreme Court's decision underscores broader debates about equality, national security, and religious freedoms. The ruling sets a precedent for addressing longstanding social divisions and reshaping policies regarding military service obligations.

Prime Minister Netanyahu, who is facing mounting criticism over his handling of the Gaza conflict and internal political tensions, is likely to face increased pressure both domestically and internationally in the coming weeks. The fallout from this ruling could potentially reshape Israel's political landscape, influencing future policies and electoral outcomes.